Home · Articles

This or That Questions vs Would You Rather Questions

Both formats offer two choices. They do not do the same conversational work. This or that questions usually name two familiar items and ask for a preference. Would you rather questions place those preferences inside a small invented situation, so the answer carries a bit of story.

Neither format is a test. A choice is a preference, not a personality score. Either Way Studio only uses the would you rather shape, because the extra sentence of situation gives a group more to talk about after the vote.

Simple preferences

A this-or-that prompt is short on purpose:

These work when you need a fast icebreaker, when the group is large, or when people are still arriving and cannot hear a long setup. They also work for people who dislike hypotheticals. The answer can be one word. You can play a dozen of them in a few minutes.

The limitation is the same as the strength. Once everyone has said “coffee,” there may be nowhere else to go unless someone volunteers a story. Some groups will. Many will not, especially classrooms and mixed-age tables.

Imaginative dilemmas

A would you rather question keeps two clear options, but each option is a small scene. From this site’s dataset:

You can still answer in one breath. You can also talk about weather, packing, guests, or what “useful” would mean. The follow-up printed with each prompt is a nudge in that direction: “What would you want to notice first when you arrived?” is more useful than “Why?” on its own.

The options still have to be meaningfully different. “Coffee or slightly cooler coffee” is a preference hair-split. “Warm bread nearby or cold fruit nearby” is a real fork, even though both are ordinary foods.

When each format works well

Use this or that when

The room is noisy. You have sixty seconds. People do not share a language for long hypotheticals. You are lining up for something and only need a spark. You want a show of hands and then you need to start the actual meeting.

Use would you rather when

You have five to twenty minutes. You want reasons, not just labels. You are on a drive, at a table, or in a classroom warm-up that can survive one extra sentence. You want a printable card that still makes sense if it sits on a table by itself.

Family nights usually want the fuller form, because children can argue for a floating treehouse in a way they cannot argue for “tea.” Friend groups can use either; Funny Choices on this site sit between the two, because the options are silly but still scenes.

Icebreaker ideas

For a group that has never met, start with one this-or-that question everyone can answer from the chair: window or aisle, soup or sandwich. Then ask one would you rather question from Everyday Life or Food and Snacks. Everyday prompts stay close to real habits, so they do not feel like theater.

For a group that already knows each other, skip the one-word layer. Open with Friends or Imagination. A prompt about planning a surprise day versus receiving one will surface how people like to be cared for without turning into a survey.

The random question station is useful here. Press Surprise Me, read the category label, and if the prompt is too odd for the room, press it again. Random draws do not disturb a ten-question round running elsewhere on the same page.

How to turn this-or-that into would you rather

Keep both items. Add a constraint, a place, or a stretch of time so the preference has to live somewhere.

Tea or coffee? becomes “Would you rather have a thermos of soup or a thermos of cocoa on a cold walk?” The drink is still there, but now there is weather and a halfway point.

Window or aisle? becomes “Would you rather have a window seat on a bus or an aisle seat on a train?” The travel object changed, so the answer is about access and view, not a habit slogan.

Notebook or loose paper? becomes “Would you rather journal on lined paper or sketch on blank paper at the end of a trip day?” You still pick a surface, but you also pick a way of remembering.

Morning walk or evening walk? becomes “Would you rather have a quiet hour after dinner or a quiet hour before anyone else wakes?” The walk can disappear; the scarce resource—quiet—stays.

Check three things after you rewrite. Both options should be understandable without extra lore. They should not humiliate anyone. They should not demand private financial or medical facts. If you cannot explain the prompt in one breath, it is too long for a card.

Mixing the two in one evening

A practical sequence: two this-or-that questions to hear voices, then a ten-question would you rather round from one category, then one printed card as a closer. If energy drops, stop. The group play guide covers skip rules and how to handle a split vote without turning it into a contest.

If you only have this-or-that energy, stay there. Forcing a dilemma on a tired table makes people pick at random and then feel foolish for having to explain. Random picking is allowed; forced explanation is not.

If you want more ready-made dilemmas instead of writing your own, the list of 100 questions and the live table on the homepage use the same dataset.

FAQ

Are this or that questions worse?
No. They are faster. Use them when speed is the point.
Does a longer question mean a deeper person?
No. Length is a conversation tool, not a measure of character.
Can I print this-or-that cards from this site?
The print tool prints would you rather cards from the 240-question set. You can still write short preference cards by hand if you want a mixed deck.
Where should I start if I am unsure?
Open the random question station, draw one prompt, and see whether the group answers in one word or in a paragraph. Adjust from there.